Skip to content

As Seen On:

Best Seller!

Eat Like the 
AMISH

Traditional Amish Recipe

100% Family Owned

Perfect for Desserts, Snacks, or on Fruit or Bread

Proudly Made in the USA!

Get My Amish Peanut Butter Now!

30-Day Money Back Guarantee

What Our Customers Are Saying:

What Our Customers Are Saying

What Makes Us Different?

We aren't your average foods company. Here's what sets us apart...

Them

Family Owned

Traditional Recipe

Authentic Amish Heritage

Made in the USA

Get Mine Now!

All Orders Include a 30-Day Money Back Guarantee

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Yoder's have any allergy warnings?

Yes, please be aware Yoder's Amish Peanut Butter contains both Peanuts and Egg Whites.

How should I store my Yoder's Amish Peanut Butter?

Unopened Yoder's can be stored in a cupboard or pantry. Once opened, please refrigerate. 

Where is Yoder's made?

Yoder's Amish Peanut Butter is manufactured in Ohio, USA - the heart of Amish Country.

Who owns Yoder's?

Yoder's is a 100% family owned business with authentic, generational Amish roots. 

About Us
The Yoder's Story

Yoder’s Amish Foods is a 100% family owned Amish Foods Store based in Goshen, IN. With authentic Amish heritage, we saw a gap in the market to bring our traditional Amish goods online.

 

We are located just 20 minutes outside of Shipshewana, which is home to the largest Amish population in Indiana.

 

Indiana is home to over 60,000 Amish residents, which makes up almost 1/6 of the entire Amish population in the USA.

 

All of our products are FDA Approved and Made in the United States by local Amish and Mennonite employees.

 

We hope you feel the same pride we do when you enjoy our delicious offerings.

Contact Us

We'll be in touch with you shortly.

Thanks for contacting us. We'll get back to you as soon as possible.

NAME

EMAIL

MESSAGE